Exemption Clauses Essay

Exclusion Clause Eassy Sample Essay

1614 WordsSep 14th, 20097 Pages

A.
Introduction
Joe (“J”) is attempting to sue Dazzle Dry Cleaners (“D”) for compensation for the loss occurred due carelessness of D. D will defend itself likely by proving exclusion clause as a part of the terms of its contract with J. In order to advice J it necessary to determine whether the clause has a contractual effect. Secondly it is necessary to determine the terms of the contract and analyse if creation of such clause protects the party relying on it from the consequence of breach. Finally if it’s rendered ineffective by any statue which make D liable for damage, should be discussed.
Contractual Effects of the Contract
In this case main question that arises is whether the exclusion clause is part of terms of contract.…show more content…

Even if D proves exclusion clause part of the contract does not save it from claiming of damages. In order to defend itself D has to prove the damage caused by negligence of the staff members in handling the shirt and losing to a customer who claims to have lost his ticket is a part of exclusion clause. Therefore there is a need of proper interpretation of exclusion clause by examining its language .
The clause here mentions the words “any loss or damage” and “regardless of how that loss caused” may protects D from any claims, but the meaning of the words used is too vast and does not specify nature of the damage and loss thus clause is construed Contra proferentem .
Whereas, following White v John Warwick , ambiguous wording out of exclusion clause would effectively protect D from their strict contractual liability towards J, but it would not exempt them from liability in negligence. Liability of negligence can only be excluded if clearly expressed .
Thus the facts show there was negligence by the staff of D leading to loss cause to J. There is a stress on exclusion clause as a part of contract which might be a deciding factor in this case. Also it is a business contract so it is assumed to create a legal relation between parties (J and D).
Protection against the Breach
In order to determine the terms of the contract it is

Show More

Exclusion Clauses In Contracts Essay

The exclusion clause is an important device for allocating the risks between the contractual parties. However, the exclusion clauses could mostly be found in written contracts, especially standard form of contracts. Standard form contracts with consumers are often contained in some printed ticket, or delivery note, or receipt, or similar document. In practice, it is very common that if a person wants the product, he may have no alternative but to accept the terms drawn up by the other party even though such terms are disadvantage to him, or he may simply accept it regardless the possible unfavorable position because he does not trouble to read a long list of terms and conditions. Therefore, contracts are regularly signed, tickets are simply accepted, or a tick-box on a website is clicked, commonly between large companies and individual consumers.
Both the common law and the statutory law have recognized the weaker position of consumers. It is well established an exclusion clause will be valid and enforceable only if it is incorporated in the contract, use clear wordings and does not contravene statutory limits. In order to limit the unfairness resulting from exclusion clauses, the courts have developed certain principles such as the doctrine of non est factum in signature cases, ‘red ink-red hand’ principle in relation to ‘onerous or unusual’ terms, contra proferentem rule when interpreting ambiguous exclusion clauses and ‘fundamental breach’ principle.
It is well established that an exclusion clause will be valid and enforceable only if it is incorporated into the contract. There are several ways in which exclusion clauses can be incorporated into contracts . One way is by giving a sufficient notice. In J Spurling v Bradshaw,_ the defendant stored goods in the plaintiffs’ warehouse regularly. On one occasion, the defendant stored eight barrels of orange juice but some were damaged so he refused to pay. The plaintiffs relied on the exemption clause exempt them from liability for any negligence. The defendant contended that the exempting condition was not part of the contract since he had never read the conditions. In respect of giving a notice, firstly, the notice must be given before the time of contracting. In Olley v Marlborough Court Hotel Ltd, the court found a notice, which came after the contract was made, excluding liability for stolen items was not incorporated into the contract. Secondly, reasonable sufficient notice must be given. In Parker v South Eastern Railway, Mellish LJ found that if the defendant took reasonable steps to give notice of conditions, a person will still be bound by the exclusion clause if he knows that there was writing contained on the ticket, but does not know or believe if the writing contained conditions. In respect of giving a notice of onerous or unusual terms , the court apply the stricter approach to better protect the customers. In Spurling case, the court held the plaintiff was protected by...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

The Role of Hardship Clauses in Controlling Liability by Contract

3482 words - 14 pages The Role of Hardship Clauses in Controlling Liability by Contract Introduction The fundamental principle of the law of contract is that the parties to a contract must carry out their contractual obligations. The principle of hardship operates as a modification of the principle of pacta sunt servanda; it gives relief to a party where performance of a contractual obligation due to change of circumstances becomes ...

B law Essay

2070 words - 8 pages Question 1: a)This problem question contains various issues that need to be explored. However, the two major issues that need to be argued are whether or not a contract exists between the parties and if the reasonable notice has been given.For the first issue, to be legally classified as a valid simple contract, there are three essential elements:Elements of contract:(1). Agreement in the form of an offer and...

Contract Law

8517 words - 34 pages Introduction.Ask any one you know to describe a contract, they will mention paperwork that you sign when you start a job or college, renting or buying a house. These are contracts, but in the law this term has a much wider meaning, covering any legally binding agreement, written or not written. We make contracts when we buy goods at a shop and when we get a bus, sometimes it is made without a word being spoken or written down. A...

Contract Creation and Management

1615 words - 6 pages Contracts, no matter how large or complex, are promises negotiated between parties and should be written to ensure business agreements are fulfilled by both parties. Clarity of purpose is the hallmark of successful contracts because contracts are never free of interpretation (University of Phoenix, 2009) and poorly written contracts can ultimately result in breached contracts....

Business Law Test Study Notes Review

1250 words - 5 pages Business Law - Test Study Notes ReviewCONTRACTS - Written. Oral. Implied.Freedom of contract - what parties agreed to in the first place is unrestricted to the court. Equal bargaining position. Acting Voluntarily.People can enter in any kind of contract as long as it meets the common law requirements.Law of contracts: common law or case law.CONSENSUS - parties must reach a mutual agreement. Equal bargaining...

The Employer/Employee Relationship

2732 words - 11 pages How difficult (or easy) is it for an employer to prevent an employee working for others (or themselves), both during the employment and after it has ended? Refer to relevant cases and legislation. This essay will look at the definition of what an employer and employee are according to legislation. It will then discuss whether or not an employer can prevent an employee from working for others (or themselves), after the employment has ended. ...

HMO Regulation

1764 words - 7 pages HMO Regulation Health Maintenance Organizations, or HMO's, are a very important part of the American health care system. They involve elements such as beneficial health care programs like Medicare for seniors and Medicaid for the poor. HMO's are sometimes referred to as managed care programs, which involves participation through clinics, physicians and insurance companies. Other essential parts of HMO's include prescription drug plans,...

Sale of Goods Act

2000 words - 8 pages A Section 13 (1) of the sale of goods act provides that where a good is sold by description the good must correspond with the description. The description of the good should be accurate and if the goods do not match the description the buyer is entitled to a remedy. This implied term only applies to goods sold solely by description and does not apply where the buyer inspects the goods before the purchase . In Harlington & Leinster v Christopher...

Law for Business: English Contract Law Assignment. Submit a report that investigates your dealings with a client named Babyburp PLC.

2180 words - 9 pages 1.0IntroductionThis report considers the legal implications of Fillitup's dealings with Babyburp, advises on any possible legal liability and how to avoid liability in the future. Legal implications arising from dealings with Babyburp Ltd will be covered by the Sale of Goods Act 1979 (SoGA 1979) and the

Virtual Organization E-Business Paper: Smith Systems Consulting

1355 words - 5 pages AbstractThis Virtual Organization E-Business Paper will focus on Smith Systems Consulting. As Smith Systems expands, it will increasingly conduct e-business on an international basis.As such, this paper will address the following:a. Analyze the legal issues that the company may face when conducting ebusiness and discuss possible solutions; andb. Identify issues that may arise in the company's international business...

‘Consequential loss’ is a term which often appears in contracts and agreements

2496 words - 10 pages Consequential loss is an important element in a contract and an agreement that would have a big difference of compensation either to include this clause in the contract or not when the contract is breached. Consequential loss's definition is keep changing through the development of the law. Hadley v Baxendale,

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *